What can cemented carbide do except serving as tools and industrial raw materials？Tesla’s futuristic and rugged Cybertruck has drawn attention not only for its unique appearance but also for its promised functionalities. One feature that has garnered widespread interest is Elon Musk’s implication of a potential tungsten carbide coating, which would make the Cybertruck scratch-resistant—impervious to scratches from all objects except those with diamond-level hardness. But how is the coating made? how does it compare to coatings used by other brands and aftermarket coating solutions?
Tungsten carbide is a compound composed of tungsten and carbon atoms, renowned for its exceptional hardness that rivals that of diamonds. Owing to its wear-resistant properties, it is primarily used in industrial settings. For the Cybertruck, this coating would revolutionize vehicle exterior protection, significantly enhancing its resistance to scratches and potential damage.
Traditionally, the application of tungsten carbide involves high-energy processes, namely High-Velocity Oxygen Fuel (HVOF) spraying or Physical Vapor Deposition (PVD). These processes require specialized equipment and a level of expertise uncommon in automotive manufacturing, making Tesla’s potential venture into this coating even more remarkable.
High-Velocity Oxygen Fuel (HVOF) Spraying Technology
As a key branch of thermal spraying technology, HVOF spraying generates high-velocity gas flow through high-energy combustion. It accelerates cemented carbide powder (or other wear-resistant/corrosion-resistant powders) to supersonic speeds, which then impact the substrate surface to form a dense coating with high bonding strength. Its core principle lies in “densification through high-velocity impact.”
- Energy Source: Fuels such as kerosene or propane are mixed with oxygen in specific proportions and burned under high pressure in a combustion chamber. This produces a supersonic gas flow with a temperature of approximately 2000–3000°C and a velocity of 1500–2500 m/s—far higher than the 300–500 m/s of traditional flame spraying.
- Powder Acceleration and Deposition: Cemented carbide powders (e.g., WC-Co, WC-Ni, typically with a particle size of 10–45 μm) are fed into the high-temperature, high-velocity gas flow by a carrier gas (e.g., nitrogen). The powders are rapidly heated to a “semi-molten/plastic state” and impact the surface of the cemented carbide substrate with extremely high kinetic energy.
- Coating Formation: The high-velocity impact causes severe plastic deformation of the powder particles, which stack tightly and form a “mechanical bond + micro-metallurgical bond” with the substrate.
-
The quality of HVOF-sprayed coatings highly depends on parameter control. Key parameters are as follows:
High Density
Porosity is extremely low (<1%), far superior to traditional flame spraying (5%–10%), resulting in stronger corrosion and wear resistance.
High Bonding Strength
The bonding strength between the coating and cemented carbide substrate can reach 50–100 MPa (only 20–30 MPa for traditional flame spraying), making it less likely to peel off.
Minimal Component Loss
The supersonic gas flow cools quickly, leading to a low decomposition rate (<5%) of cemented carbide powders (e.g., WC) and avoiding increased coating brittleness.
Flexible Coating Thickness
Coatings with a thickness of 50–500 μm can be prepared, suitable for scenarios with different wear requirements (e.g., edge strengthening of cutting tools, surface repair of molds).
Residual Stress in Coatings: High-velocity impact and thermal contraction easily cause compressive stress in the coating, and thick coatings may face cracking risks.
High Equipment Costs: The investment in HVOF equipment (spray guns, combustion chambers, high-pressure gas supply systems) and operating costs (fuel and oxygen consumption) are higher than those of traditional spraying.
Unsuitability for Complex Surfaces: The spray gun has a limited spray angle (usually requiring >45°), making it difficult to uniformly coat complex structures such as narrow holes and deep cavities.
Oil Drilling Tools: WC-NiCr coatings are applied to the surfaces of cemented carbide drill bits to enhance resistance to mud corrosion and impact wear.
Mold Repair: HVOF-sprayed repair coatings (100–200 μm thick) are used on worn surfaces of cemented carbide cold-working molds, extending their service life by over 50%.
PVD is a type of vapor deposition technology. In a vacuum environment, physical methods (e.g., evaporation, sputtering, ionization) are used to convert cemented carbide coating materials into gaseous atoms/ions, which then deposit on the surface of the cemented carbide substrate to form a thin-film coating. Its core principle is “atomic-level deposition in a vacuum environment.” Based on the vaporization method of the coating material, PVD is mainly divided into three categories: Evaporation Deposition (EVAP), Sputtering Deposition, and Ion Plating. Among these, magnetron sputtering and arc ion plating are most widely used in the cemented carbide field.
Principle: In a vacuum chamber, the cemented carbide coating material (e.g., TiN, TiAlN, CrN, made into a “target”) serves as the cathode. An inert gas (e.g., Ar) is introduced, and a high voltage is applied to ionize Ar into plasma. Ar⁺ ions in the plasma bombard the target surface under the action of an electric field, “sputtering” target atoms. These sputtered atoms diffuse to the surface of the cemented carbide substrate and deposit to form a thin film.
Characteristics: The coating has a uniform composition (consistent with the target), controllable thickness (with an accuracy of 1–5 nm), and the substrate temperature is low (usually <200°C, preventing softening of the cemented carbide substrate).
Principle: In a vacuum environment, a cathode arc discharge (with the target as the cathode, generating a high-temperature arc) is used to evaporate and ionize the cemented carbide target (e.g., Ti, Al alloys) into high-energy ions (ionization rate >80%). At the same time, a reactive gas (e.g., N₂, O₂) is introduced, and the ions react with the reactive gas on the substrate surface to form a compound coating (e.g., TiN, Al₂O₃).
Characteristics: The ions have high energy, resulting in high bonding strength between the coating and substrate (up to 80–150 MPa), high coating density, and the ability to prepare high-hardness coatings (HV 2000–3000).
PVD processes are sensitive to parameters such as vacuum degree, temperature, and ion energy. Core parameters are as follows:
Thin and Uniform Coating: The thickness is usually 0.5–10 μm, suitable for precision components (e.g., edges of cemented carbide cutting tools) without affecting the dimensional accuracy of the workpiece.
High Hardness and High Temperature Resistance: PVD coatings such as TiAlN and AlCrN have a hardness of HV 2500–3500 and can withstand temperatures of 800–1100°C, far exceeding the cemented carbide substrate (which tolerates temperatures of approximately 600°C).
Low Friction Coefficient: The coating surface is smooth (Ra < 0.2 μm) and has a low friction coefficient (e.g., the friction coefficient of TiN coating against steel is approximately 0.4, much lower than the 0.6–0.8 of cemented carbide), reducing heat generation during cutting/wear processes.
Environmental Friendliness and No Pollution: The entire process is carried out in a vacuum environment, with no waste liquid or gas emissions, meeting the requirements of green manufacturing.
Low Deposition Efficiency: The coating growth rate is slow (typically 0.1–1 μm/h), making it unsuitable for thick coating preparation.
High Equipment Investment: The costs of vacuum systems, targets, and plasma control equipment are high, making it economical for mass production but not for small-batch processing.
Poor Coverage of Complex Structures: It is difficult to uniformly deposit coatings inside structures such as deep holes and narrow gaps (special tooling assistance is required).
Many automotive brands prioritize protecting their vehicle exteriors, typically using transparent polyurethane coatings. This transparent layer is applied over the paint to provide a buffer against minor scratches and protect against UV radiation. While effective for daily use, its protective capabilities are not on par with those of tungsten carbide.
Some high-end automotive brands like Audi use ceramic coatings, which are made of silica and offer enhanced protection. These coatings bond with the paint to form a hardened protective layer, featuring hydrophobic properties, UV damage resistance, and some scratch resistance. However, if Tesla delivers on its promise, even these premium solutions may struggle to compete with the exceptional hardness of tungsten carbide.
The automotive aftermarket offers numerous solutions designed to enhance vehicle protection and aesthetic appeal:
- Ceramic Coatings: Popular for their balance of protection and aesthetic enhancement, they provide UV protection, hydrophobic properties, and a certain degree of scratch resistance.
- Nano (or Glass) Coatings: Similar to ceramic coatings but bond at the molecular level, offering UV protection, hydrophobic properties, and resistance to contaminants.
- Polymer Coatings: Easier to apply than ceramic coatings, they are usually less durable but still provide good protection against contaminants and minor scratches.
- Graphene Coatings: Known for their hydrophobicity, UV protection, and water spot resistance, they also stay cool under direct sunlight.
- Self-Healing Coatings: Advanced polymer solutions that “heal” minor scratches when exposed to heat.
While all these coatings offer varying degrees of protection and aesthetic benefits, none can match the potential scratch resistance of tungsten carbide. However, tungsten carbide poses significant challenges as an aftermarket solution:
- Professional Application: Processes like HVOF or PVD are not standard equipment in automotive service shops (including 4S dealerships).
- Adhesion: Ensuring the coating adheres effectively to the vehicle’s paint or metal is crucial.
- Brittleness: Despite its hardness, tungsten carbide is also brittle, which may lead to compatibility issues with vehicle parts that are prone to bending or impact.
Musk’s proposal to equip the Cybertruck with a tungsten carbide coating marks another innovation in automotive body technology. If successful, Tesla will set a new gold standard for vehicle protection. Other brands may follow suit, exploring the integration of such high-end protective coatings into their manufacturing processes.
In summary, the potential tungsten carbide coating for the Cybertruck not only symbolizes a step forward for Tesla but also challenges the broader automotive industry to innovate and rethink vehicle protection. Only time will tell if this promise becomes a widespread reality.
English 
Español 
हिन्दी 
العربية 
Português do Brasil 
Русский 
日本語 
Deutsch 
한국어 
Français 
Türkçe 
Polski 
Tiếng Việt 
Italiano 
简体中文 
